carriagehouse menu header

MENUS

MACKINAC ISLAND RESTAURANTS

Fresh Local Flavors

What makes our Mackinac Island restaurant stand out? For starters, we work overtime to source the freshest seafood from Lake Superior, the finest cuts of meat from our Detroit-based family butcher, and loads of organic produce from our own network of local farmers. We’re sure you’ll taste it in every bite.

Our Menus

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Verandah
  • Dessert
  • Drinks

Lunch

Appetizers

Chilled Vegetable Gazpacho

$11.00

French Onion Soup au Gratin

$13.00

Artisanal Farmer's Board

$32.00

Smoked Whitefish with Crostini

$19.00

Salads

Grilled Shrimp and Asparagus Salad

$29.00

Mixed greens, artichoke hearts, asparagus, feta cheeses and lemon-caper vinaigrette

Caesar Salad With Beef Tenderloin

$32.00

Grilled Shrimp

$29.00

Seafood Salad

$38.00

Lobster, shrimp, jumbo lump crab and avocado

Greek Salad

$19.00

Cucumber, olives, tomato, red onion, feta

Sandwiches

Mackinac Whitefish Sandwiches on Homemade Cheese-Dill Bread

$24.00

Wagu Hamburger with Morrel Cheddar Cheese

$19.00

Add Fresh Avocato

$3.00

Add Neuske's Bacon

$4.00

Open-Faced Crab Melt

$29.00

Avocado, havarti and spinach salad

Club Sandwich

$18.00

Oven-roasted turkey, Neuske's bacon and cranberry relish

Turkey Panini Sandwich

$19.00

Mozzarella, basil pesto and roasted peppers

Ruben Sandwich

$24.00

American Wagyu Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Dressing

The Best BLT

$18.00

Jalapeño mayonnaise, Neuske's bacon and avocado

Steak Sandwich

$29.00

 Mushrooms, Onions, Provolone and Horseradish Sauce on French Bread

Grilled Vegetable Sandwich

$18.00

with Red Bell Pepper Pesto

Dinner

Appetizers

Royal Ossetra Caviar 130 or Smoked Charr Roe

$75.00

Panamanian White Shrimp with Traditional Cocktail Sauce

$19.00

Jumbo Lump Crab Tower with Fresh Salsa and Avocado

$23.00

Grilled Rib Eye Cap with Porcini Mushrooms and Horseradish Cream Sauce

$21.00

Smoked Whitefish Cakes with Mustard Vinaigrette

$15.00

Duck Pot Stickers on Red Cabbage Slaw with a Raspberry Gastrique

$18.00

Escargot with French Bread Toast Points

$18.00

Soups

French Onion Soup au Gratin

$13.00

Chilled Garden Vegetable Gazpacho

$11.00

Salads

Garden Salad of Presque Isle Farm Organic Mixed Greens

$14.00

Beet Salad with Oranges, Watermelon and Crumbled Blue Cheese

$16.00

Goat Cheese Salad with Baby Spinach, Pecan, Sun-dried Cherries and Bacon

$17.00

Entrées

Carriage House Lake Superior Whitefish

$39.00

Pan Seared Diver Scallops

$48.00

With Lemongrass, Ginger, Vermouth, Frizzled Leeks and Wild Mushroom Risotto

Cesse Fiocchi Pasta

$34.00

Add Morel Mushrooms

$17.00

Add Grilled Shrimp

$14.00

With Sauteed Zucchini, Summer Squash and a Creamed Fresh Basil Pesto Sauce

Seafood Mediterranean Pasta Seafood Mediterranean Pasta with Shrimp, Scallops, Calamari an

$43.00

Saffron Angel Hair Pasta with Tomato Caper White Wine and Herb Concasse

Veal Piccata with Basil Peston Fettuccine Alfredo

$45.00

Berkshire Tomahawk Pork Chop with Wild Rice

$43.00

American Wagyu 14oz Kansas City Strip

$78.00

Carriage House Creekstone Farms 8oz. Filet Mignon with Sauce Bearnaise

$58.00

Add Split Lobster

$26.00

Add Sauteed Morel Mushrooms

$17.00

Add Green Hill Danish Blue Cheese

$7.00

Verandah

Verandah Menu

Artisanal Farmer's Board

$32.00

Shrimp Cocktail

$19.00

Duck Pot Stickers on Red Cabbage Slaw with a Raspberry Gastrique

$18.00

Royal Ossetra Caviar

$130.00

Smoked Char Roe

$75.00

Smoked Fish Trio with Crostini

$18.00

Homemade Potato Chips with Chipotle Ranch Dip

$12.00

Iroquois Hot Fudge Ice Cream Puff

$12.00

Peanut Butter Pie with Iroquois Hot Fudge

$12.00

Homemade Lemon Meringue Pie

$12.00

Dessert

Sweets

Iroquois Hot Fudge Ice Cream Puff

$12.00

Peanut Butter Pie with Iroquois Hot Fudge

$12.00

Mackinac Tin Roof or Iroquois Hot Fudge Sundae

$12.00

Homemade Lemon Meringue Pie

$12.00

Treats

Hummer Up the Hill

$19.00

Vanilla ice cream, ground nutmeg, Kahlua, light and dark rum

Grasshopper

$19.00

Vanilla ice cream, green crème de menthe and light crème de cacao

Harbor Moon

$19.00

Ketel One orange vodka, peach schnapps, orange sherbet, and vanilla ice cream

After Dinner Drinks

Dow's 10yr Tawney Port

$12.00

Graham’s 2000 Vintage Port

$23.00

Dow's 20yr Tawney Port

$27.00

Frostbitten Ice Wine

$14.00

Dalmore King Alexander III

$62.00

Dalmore King Alexander

$60.00

Johnnie Walker Blue Blended Scotch

$30.00

The MacCallan 12yr Double Cask

$20.00

Oban 14yr Single Malt Scotch

$14.00

The Glenlivet 12yr Single Malt Scotch

$12.00

Ardbeg 10yr Single Malt Scotch

$12.00

Glenmorangie 10yr Single Malt Scotch

$11.00

Glen Fiddich 12yr Single Malt Scotch

$14.00

Larceny Bourbon

$16.00

Hudson Bay Baby Bourbon

$20.00

Jefferson's Ocean - Aged at Sea Bourbon

$29.00

Hennessey XO Cognac

$33.00

Remy Martin VSOP Cognac

$13.00

Couvoisier VS

$12.00

Don Julio 1942 Anjeo Tequila

$24.00

1800 Milenio Tequila

$41.00

Drinks

Custom Cocktails

Mackinac Arts Mule

Belvedere ginger zest vodka, ginger beer, lime, served in a copper mug

Berry Picker

Belvedere citrus vodka, fresh berries, lemonade

French 75 Martini

Hendrick's gin, lemon, Chandon sparkling wine

Old Fashion Rye

Classic old-fashioned made with Detroit City Rye

Bellini Martini

Belvedere vodka, peach puree, Chandon

Aperol Spritzer

Aperol, Prosecco, soda, orange bitters

Mrs. Mac Cosmo

Belvedere citrus vodka, Cointreau, fresh squeezed lime, cranberry

La Paloma

Patron Silver Tequila, St. Geermain, grapefruit, lime

Cucumber Gimblet

Effen Vodka, St. Germain, muddled cucumber

By the Glass

Chardonnay, Cakebread

$25.00

Napa

Chardonnay, Trig Point

$15.50

Sonoma

Chenin Blanc/Viognier

$11.50

Terra d’Oro – Clarksburg

Sancerre, Fourtnier Grand Cuvee

$23.00

France

Sauvignon Blanc, Daybreak

$11.00

New Zealand

Pinot Grigio, Monteflor Velio

$11.00

Italy

Riesling, Dr. Hermann

$10.50

Germany

Rosé, Domaine Houchart

$11.00

France

Moscato D'Asti, Honey Bubbles

$11.00

Cabernet Sauvignon Two Old Dogs

$25.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Torchbearer

$18.00

California

Cabernet Sauvignon, Thirty5

$10.50

California

Red Blend, Federalist Dueling Pistols

$20.50

Creek Valley

Pinot Noir, Ayers

$17.50

Willamette Valley

Malbec, Terrazas

$13.00

Argentina

Merlot, Domaine Sonoma

$11.00

Sonoma County

Sparkling Rosé, Faire la Fête

$15.00

France

Sparkling Wine, Domaine Chandon

$12.00

California NV

By the Bottle

Joseph Phelps ‘Insignia’

$450.00

Napa

Quintessa

$375.00

Napa

Newton 'The Puzzle'

$330.00

Napa 2016

Stags’ Leap ‘The Investor’

$150.00

Napa

Trujillo ‘Madelyn’ Red Cuvee

$120.00

Napa

Paraduxx 'Proprietary'

$112.00

Napa 2017

Federalist 'Dueling Pistols'

$78.00

Dry Creek Valley 2016

Quinta Sardonia ‘Sardon’

$44.00

Spain

Cabernet Sauvignon, Trujillo Morisoli Reserve

$300.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Orin Swift ‘Mercury Head'

$300.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Silver Oak

$170.00

Alexander Valley 2016

Cabernet Sauvignon, Far Niente

$250.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Paul Hobbs

$230.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Nickel & Nickel 'Quarry'

$220.00

Napa

Cabernet Sauvignon, Caymus

$205.00

Napa 2019

Cabernet Sauvignon, Adaptation

$150.00

Napa 2017

Cabernet Sauvignon, Faust

$138.00

Napa - 2018

Cabernet Sauvignon, Two Old Dogs - Napa

$96.00

Napa 2018

Cabernet Sauvignon, Five Vinters

$80.00

Napa 2018

Cabernet Sauvignon, Round Pond 'Kith & Kin'

$72.00

Napa 2018

Cabernet Sauvignon, Torchbearer

$68.00

Napa 2018

Cabernet Sauvignon, Auctioneer

$58.00

Napa 2018

 

Cabernet Sauvignon, Thirty5

$38.00

California

Amarone, Begali Classico

$120.00

Italy 2015

Chateuneuf du Pape, D' Arneval

$115.00

France

Bordeaux, Chateau Marsac Seguineau

$90.00

 Margaux

Chianti, Tenuta Di Nozzole ‘Riserva’

$60.00

Italy

Pinot Noir, Sanford ‘Single Vineyard’

$140.00

Santa Rita Hills

Pinot Noir, Et Fille

$126.00

Williamette Valley

Pinot Noir, Crossbarn

$100.00

Sonoma Coast

Pinot Noir, Coleman Vineyard

$80.00

Willamette

Pinot Noir, Ayers

$66.00

Willamette Valley 2015

Malbec, Terrazas

$48.00

Sonoma County 2018

Malbec, Cigar Box

$40.00

Argentina 2019

Zinfandel, Ridge

$90.00

Paso Robles 2019

Petite Sirah, Stags Leap

$100.00

Napa 2017

Shiraz, Mollydooker 'Boxer

$64.00

South Australia, 2018

Merlot, Domaine Sonoma

$40.00

Sonoma County 2018

Chardonnay, Kongsgaard

$260.00

Napa 2018

Chardonnay, Far Niente

$150.00

Napa 2018

Chardonnay, PlumpJack

$135.00

Napa 2018

Chardonnay, Cakebread

$98.00

Napa 2018

Chardonnay, Rombauer

$90.00

Carneros

Chardonnay, Jordan

$70.00

Sonoma 2018

Chardonnay, Trig Point

$58.00

Sonoma 2017

Chenin Blanc/Viognier, Terra d’Oro

$42.00

Clarksburg

Chablis Reserve, Domaine de Vauroux

$96.00

France

Riesling, Dr. Hermann

$38.00

Germany 2018

Gewurztraminer, Ciccone

$42.00

Michigan

Sancerre, Fourtnier Grand Cuvee

$88.00

France

Sauvignon Blanc, Cloudy Bay

$70.00

Marlborough, New Zealand

Sauvignon Blanc, Cakebread

$60.00

Napa 2019

Sauvignon Blanc, Decoy

$42.00

Sonoma 2020

Sauvignon Blanc, Daybreak

$40.00

Marlborough

Rose, Triennes

$47.00

France 2019

Rosé, Domaine Houchart

$42.00

 France

Pinot Grigio, Vie de Romans

$82.00

Italy

Pinot Grigio, Monteflor Velio

$40.00

Italy 2019

Moscato, Honey Bubbles

$40.00

Italy NV

Champagne & Sparkling Wine

Dom Perignon

$300.00

France

Ruinart Blanc de Blanc

$150.00

Ruinart Rose

$150.00

Veuve Clicquot 'Yellow Label'

$112.00

France

Jacquart, Mosaïque Rosé

$110.00

France

Duval-Leroy, Brut

$90.00

France

Domaine Chandon, Brut

$44.00

Napa

Ca Furlan, Prosecco

$40.00

Italy